Joe Bruno on Boxing — Why the Boxing Writer Awards Are Meaningless

Joe Bruno on Boxing

By Joe Bruno—Former Vice President of the New York Boxing Writers
Association and the International Boxing Writers Association

News Item: New York Boxing Writers Announce their yearly awards.
Although they now bill themselves as the Boxing Writers of America, in early January the New York Boxing Writers did one of the two things they actually do to justify their existence (besides bending their elbows at wet luncheons), when they announced their yearly boxing awards.
Now let’s examine the dubious voting process, that somehow awarded Lennox “The Lummox” Lewis the 1999 Fighter of the Year. Lewis had two fights in 1999, both lackluster bouts with ancient and ring-worn Evander Holyfield. In the first Holyfield fight, Lewis was robbed by blind-judge officials, especially one Eugenia Williams, and their waltz was declared a draw. In the second fight, which many at ringside thought Holyfield had won (the ringside press were 3-1 in favor of Holyfield), Lewis won an uninspired 12-round unanimous decision. For this Lewis wins the NY Boxing Writers Fighter of the Year Award. How can that be? Well, if you look closely, there’s a reason, no matter how dubious and contrived.
Being a member of the New York Boxing Writers from 1979-1991, I attended many NY Boxing Writer luncheons, where the nominations were taken for their various awards. Of the 60 odd members of the NY Boxing Writers, approximately half are public relations people who work for various promoters, or television networks like HBO and Showtime, who are in the business of robbing the paying public by showcasing dreadful fight cards at $49.99 a pop. Some of the PR people are staff. Others are freelance. But they all stuff their pockets with the boxing public’s hard earned cash, that trickles down through the dirty paws of fascists like Seth “The Shrimp” Abraham of HBO, Bob “Bullspit” Arum and Dung King
After chomping down a roast beef lunch, and quaffing more than a few cocktails, the members of the NY Boxing Writers are then asked to nominate someone for each award. In almost every case, the nomination is put forth by a PR person interested in furthering the career of a fighter, manager, or trainer, his, or her boss, has a vested interest in, and sometimes even the boss promoter himself. Only one second is needed to place this nominee’s name on the ballot.
In 1982, it got so darn ridiculous, Murray Goodman, then Dung King’s chief flack, nominated the Dungster himself for the James J. Walker Award for Long and Meritorious Service in Boxing. At that time, King had been meritoriously serving boxing, and mostly his own bank accounts, for the sum total of five years. James J. Walker, you may remember, was the notorious former Mayor of New York City, who resigned his office in disgrace, after being caught with his felonious hand in the till. So maybe Dung King winning an award named after a famous crook wasn’t such a bad idea after all. Still, in 1982, Eddie Futch won the James J. Walker Award in a landslide victory of good versus hairy evil.
After six nominees are selected for each award, the luncheon comes to an end, and the real drinking begins, at the expense of the NY Boxing Writer’s checking account, of course. Sportswriters in general, and boxing writers in particular, are notorious freeloaders, and extremely tight tippers to the restaurant staff to boot.
I once raised the ire of an old time scribe at a NY Boxing Writers luncheon, by having the audacity to tip the bartender/waiter a ten spot, after I had imbibed about half a dozen Bloody Marys, several beers and a roast beef lunch. Foolishly, I thought it was the decent thing to do.
“Don’t spoil it for the rest of us,” I was chided, by this relic with a red nose, who had obviously had never worked for tips.
So after the luncheon is over, the secretary of the NY Boxing Writers, the truly lovable Tommy Kenville, for as long as I can remember, puts the nominations into an envelope and mails them out to all the members, even to the PR flunkies who work for the greedy promoters. The members then scribble in their votes, and a few weeks later, the president and vice president of the NY Boxing Writers, along with Kenville as the scorekeeper, tally up the votes.
Being the vice president from 1982-86, I was present at several of the vote counting sessions. I once saw the President Barney Nagler take one of the ballots he emphatically disagreed with, tear it up into little pieces and dump them into the trash. So much for one person, one vote. (This same dwarfish despot, as I was reading the first page of my four-page speech to present Tommy Kenville with the Walker Award in 1985, behind my back, tore up the remaining three pages of my speech, and I was forced with a red face to stammer, “And without further ado, I present you Tommy Kenville.)
So now you understand how the system works, and why we can never take the NY Boxing Writer’s awards, or their awards dinner seriously until the rules are changed to allow only real boxing writers to vote for the awards. But since more than half the present voting group are PR people, that has about as much of a chance of happening as Don King and Bob Arum going shopping for silverware together.
What an amusing thought. I wonder who would wear the tight skirt?

Advertisements

One Response to “Joe Bruno on Boxing — Why the Boxing Writer Awards Are Meaningless”

  1. Oscar Palomino Says:

    They even mention last year 2014 boxing trainers who had a better year in boxing than those that we see every single time around HBO or Showtime broadcasting channels.
    There’s not a path or a rule for this guys to follow in order to at least recognize the great job that others are doing for this sport.

    A shameless group of people w/o ethic of work.

    They don’t even know what’s going on probably in the rest of the country with boxing, specially with the amateurism concept of today, where the base of younger fighters is going down one year after another one.

    Just take a look to the USA team on WSB now, the basement of everything and tell me, how many of those fighters are going to be an Olympic champion or a great star in the future?…Maybe one.
    And I don’t see anybody with the power of pen, qualify to put or set order through his writing mention anything of this.

    To those “mequetrefes” (dumbass),who write, decide and take those wrong decision in boxing, PLEASE TAKE A LOOK to this on top, a declaration of what is right and wrong…I hope one of you read this !!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: